Weiner Law Group LLP
Call Us Today For Your Free Consultation
866-899-1138

Using Comma-Sense

berutti jpg

While this is a bit odd, and a bit funny, the lesson of this case coming from the First Circuit Court of Appeals is super-important.  The failure of using an Oxford comma in a statute led to a $10,000,000 judgment being entered against a defendent, because the last two words were read together without a comma, an ambuigity that was not intended.

When writing, it is important to recognize the need for such a comma.  That is, when writing a list (John, Mary, Tim and Pete) without the comma between "Tim", and "and" causes "Tim and Pete" to be conjoined for the purposes of the list, meaning both of them.  If the writer meant the equivalent of Tim seperate from Pete, it should be "John, Mary, Tim, and Pete".  Even though the statue in question in this case probably meant that the last two items in the case were not conjoined, the failure of the comma created an ambiguity that was construed in favor of the party arguing it was meant to be conjoined.  That party won $10,000,000 as a result.

I followed this case because I already had a case where I made the same arguement regarding a statutory interpretation, and relied on the lower court's ruling (which has now been affirmed).

The lessons: Draft carefully and use the Oxford comma where required to avoid ambiguity; and if the language being used against you fails to include what should be a necessary Oxford comma, you may have hit the jackpot.  

About the Author: Ron Berutti, Esq. is a complex litigation specialist.  He is often called on to represent clients in the most difficult of cases, regardless of the subject matter.  This breadth and diversity of his litigation experience is invaluable to his clients.  He has tried both complex and general cases for institutional and individual clients , particularly in the areas of business torts, real estate, utilities, employment, and professional malpractice.  With a tenacious focus on the client's goals, Ron employs ethically creative strategies and strives to achieve the best results possible.  Ron regularly practices in the state and federal courts of New Jersey and New York at both the trial and appellate levels.   

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Contact Us For Legal Service That's Above And Beyond
Email us for A response

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Weiner Law Group LLP

Contact Us For Your Best Defense

Contact us online or at 866-899-1138 to find out how we can help you with your legal matter. Let us provide you service that's above and beyond your typical defense firm.

Office Locations

Map Map Map Map

Parsippany Office
629 Parsippany Road
Parsippany, NJ 07054

Toll Free: 866-899-1138
Fax: 973-403-0010
Parsippany Law Office Map

Bridgewater Office
1200 Rte. 22 East
Suite 10
Bridgewater, NJ 08807

Phone: 732-399-9710
Bridgewater Law Office Map

New York Office
90 Broad Street
Suite 1802
New York, NY 10004-2627

Phone: 646-273-0275
New York Law Office Map

Red Bank Office
331 Newman Springs Rd.
Bldg. 1, Suite 136
Red Bank, NJ 07701

Phone: 732-978-1210
Red Bank Law Office Map

Had a great experience?

Review Our Firm