Skip to main content
Weiner Law Group LLP. Logo
  • Departments
    • Business Divorce
    • Cannabis
    • Corporate & Business Law
    • Criminal Defense
    • Education Law
    • Family Law
      • High-Net-Worth Divorce
    • Government & Public Entity Law
    • Intellectual Property
    • Labor and Employment
    • Land Use & Environmental Law
    • Litigation
    • Estate Planning
    • Real Estate
    • Workers Compensation
  • Attorneys
  • Resources
    • New Jersey Law Blog
    • Case Results
    • Firm News
    • Live Events
  • Service Areas
    • Parsippany
      • Divorce
    • Jersey City
      • Divorce
      • High-Net-Worth Divorce
      • Prenuptial Agreements
    • Old Bridge
      • Divorce
    • Woodbridge Township
    • Bridgewater
      • Divorce
    • Clifton
      • Divorce
    • Elizabeth
      • Divorce
      • Prenuptial Agreements
    • Bergen County
      • Divorce
      • High-Net-Worth Divorce
      • Prenuptial Agreements
    • Hudson County
      • Divorce
    • Union County
    • Union City
    • North Bergen
    • Red Bank
      • Divorce
    • Hoboken
      • Prenuptial Agreements
      • High-Net-Worth Divorce
    • Livingston
      • High-Net-Worth Divorce
    • Atlantic City
    • Millburn
      • Prenuptial Agreements
    • Short Hills
  • Contact
  • Pay Online

Lawyer Confidence May Be Poor Indicator of Results

Home > Lawyer Confidence May Be Poor Indicator of Results
Schedule a Consultation
Wednesday, Aug 11, 2010 | By Jay McDaniel | Read Time: 4 minutes | Valuation

confident

Lawyers must evaluate cases and try to predict the most likely outcome.  To be successful, to attract and win clients, they must do so with confidence. A recent study of the accuracy of those predictions, however, reveals that lawyers are often overconfident and overly optimistic in their assessments of a client’s case.

A recent study published in Psychology, Public Policy and Law revealed that the more confidence a lawyer expressed in his or her ability to achieve a possible result, the more likely he or she will fail to achieve those results.  You can read the full article here (Insightful or Wishful – Lawyers Ability to Predict Case Outcomes.pdf).

The lesson appears to be that clients might want to maintain some skepticism about the results that the supremely confident lawyer predicts, even as they recognize that the statistics don’t tell the whole story.  The lawyer who doesn’t believe in a case, or who lacks confidence will have a difficult time being the zealous advocate that is the touchstone of an effective litigator.  We may not meet our lofty goals as often, but that is not to say that we don’t do better for our clients when we are confident in the case.  In our next post, we’ll take a look at predicting the outcome in a business dispute case.

How Important Is The Lawyer’s Prediction?

When choosing and working with a lawyer, we all look for someone that we believe can achieve the results that we want.  And we are attracted to the lawyer who both exudes and inspires confidence.  (I look for the same thing when I have to hire a lawyer.  The fact that I have a law degree doesn’t make much difference when I am the client.)  We aren’t likely to be attracted to a lawyer who is equivocal and uncertain about a successful outcome.

We will make decisions based on the lawyer’s assessment, important decisions. To sue or not to sue.  To settle.  To pursue the extra deposition or conduct additional discovery.  We want and need to believe in the lawyer’s judgment and expertise.  It is difficult to pursue a litigation strategy when the lawyer isn’t confident in its success.

Our need to believe, however, might be contrary to reality.  This study indicated that there is a negative correlation between the confidence of the lawyer and his or her ability to predict the outcome.

The Statistical Evidence

In a study taken primarily among civil litigators, the researchers found that the lawyers who were the most confident about the results they expected to achieve were also more likely to fail to achieve those results.  At the same time, those lawyers who were less confident were more to likely to exceed their expectations.  Women were slightly more accurate than men.  And, perhaps most surprisingly, years of experience did not seem to affect the results.

The researchers conducted surveys of lawyers concerning matters that were expected to be tried within 6-12 months.  They asked the lawyers to define the “win situation in terms of your minimum goal for the outcome of the case.”  The lawyers where then asked to give the probability that they would achieve the outcome.  The researchers then went back and determined the actual results of the matters to see how they compared to the lawyers’ predictions.

Most of the lawyers said they were 45-65 percent confident of achieving the outcome that they predicted.  These lawyers were generally accurate in their predictions, particularly among those where were 46-55 percent of the outcome.  But as the lawyers “confidence interval” exceeded 65 percent, the accuracy of their predictions deteriorated.  The most confident lawyers as a group failed to achieve their predictions about 20 percent of the time.

The least confident lawyers as a group did significantly better than their estimates, according to the researchers.  In fact those who were less than 50 percent confident underestimated the results as often as they were accurate.

Lawyers Are a Stubborn Lot

The researchers tried to determine whether the lawyers would be influenced by other factors.  The predictions and confidence levels of the lawyers did not change significantly as the case got closer to trial.  Nor were the lawyers likely to revise their predictions – or be significantly less confident – when asked to think through the negative aspects of their cases.

The opinions of the lawyers after the matter had been resolved also were not subject to major revisions.  Sixty-five percent of the more confident lawyers said they were pleased or very pleased with the outcome, although lawyers achieved their goals in only 57 percent of their cases.  When asked why the cases had failed to meet their predictions, the most frequently given response related to factual and evidentiary issues, the next most cited reason was “witness problems,” followed by “client problems.”  The least cited reason was attorney performance, including the performance of adversary counsel.

The Non-Scientific Assumptions

What is missing from the research is whether the overconfident lawyer does better for his or her clients than the lawyer who lacks confidence.  In other words, on a similar set of facts, will the client achieve a better net result with the confident lawyer or the not-so-confident lawyer.  In my opinion, the lawyer that is confident becomes a leader among the other lawyers or lawyers in the case, with the judge and with the jury.  There is a benefit to the client, however difficult it is to measure.

"*" indicates required fields

Address
HOW WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE CONTACTED? Check all that apply.
Check all that apply.
The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.
Disclaimer
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

"*" indicates required fields

For Legal Service That's Above and Beyond, Contact Weiner Law Group LLP Today All Consultations Are Confidential * Required Fields
HOW WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE CONTACTED? Check all that apply.
Check all that apply.
Completing this form does not create an attorney/client relationship between you and the attorneys of Weiner Law Group (the Firm). No attorney/client relationship occurs unless and until you sign an agreement confirming the nature and scope of representation. The Firm will maintain the information provided in this form with due care, however, do not assume confidentiality exists, until an attorney/client relationship is formed through completion of a retainer agreement. This form and any verbal consultation are for informational purposes only and do not contain legal advice. Please do not act or refrain from acting based on anything you read on this form or discuss with our attorneys prior to establishing a formal attorney/client relationship.
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Weiner Law Group LLP. Logo
  • Parsippany

    629 Parsippany Road
    Parsippany, NJ 07054

    (973) 403-1100

    (973) 403-0010

  • Red Bank

    331 Newman Springs Rd Bldg. 1, Suite 136
    Red Bank, NJ 07701

    (732) 978-1210

    (732) 978-1201

  • Bridgewater

    1200 Rte. 22 East Suite 10
    Bridgewater, NJ 08807

    (732) 399-9710

    (732) 399-9701

  • New York

    90 Broad Street Suite 1802
    New York, NY 10004-2627

    (646) 273-0275

    (732) 399-9701

  • Hoboken

    79 Hudson Street Suite 502
    Hoboken, NJ 07030

    (551) 430-7070

    (551) 430-7080

  • Bayonne

    33 W 8th Street, Second Floor
    Bayonne, New Jersey 07002

    (201) 436-1198

    (201) 436-0314

  • © 2025 Weiner Law Group LLP..
  •  | All Rights Reserved.
  •  | Sitemap
  •  | Disclaimer
Site By:

"*" indicates required fields

Contact Us for a Consultation Schedule your free consultation.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.